Why was Dutch so evil in rdr1? (2024)

He wanted a wild west forever, free of civilisation, and when it became clear that wasn't going to happen, he started to lose it. He was already losing it and getting paranoid by the time they reached Colter, but as people started to question him more and more, he fell apart. Losing Hosea was the final straw.

What was wrong with Dutch in Red Dead Redemption?

The theory posits that Dutch was left with a brain injury as a result of the blow, and that this ultimately leads to his downward spiral. It's certainly an interesting idea, but I can't help but feel it's something an insult to the excellent writing of Red Dead Redemption 2.

Is Dutch a bad guy in rdr1?

By the original Red Dead Redemption, Dutch had fully degraded from an idealistic leader to a delusional and frantic killer who immediately taunted John Marston over his relationship with Abigail, and killed a woman in order to cover his escape.

Did Dutch regret betraying Arthur?

It's never fully stated if Dutch ended up regretting how things ended with his gang, and specifically Arthur. Despite whether or not he lost his mind, or was consumed by greed, it's hard to assume he never felt any regret or remorse over how things played out.

Why did Dutch betray Arthur?

Dutch Would Have Eventually Seen Arthur As A Threat In RDR2

He repeatedly tells Arthur and others that they have to stick to his plan in order to survive, even as circ*mstances continue to worsen around them. Dutch wants to be the one in charge no matter what, and he wants his orders to be the law of the gang.

POV - You PLAY as Micah

Does Dutch regret Arthur's death?

He does regret it, because he eventually shoots Micah when John and Sadie confront him in the mountains. Dutch is just too headstrong and arrogant to admit he made a giant mistake.

Does Arthur see Dutch as a father?

The bulk of Arthur Morgan's life was spent with Dutch and Hosea, being one of the earliest members of the Van Der Linde Gang. He joined up with them at age 14, and the two of them effectively became his father figures after Arthur's parents died long before RDR2.

Why did John never mention Arthur?

Arthur's last dying efforts (in my playthrough) were to save the Marstons, and among his last words were to “not look back.” TL;DR - John doesn't mention Arthur in RDR1 because 1) It hurts him to think of Arthur, 2) He's ashamed that Arthur saved his family, 3) Arthur said to not look back.

Can you find Dutch after beating rdr2?

Dutch Van der Linde walks away unharmed at the end of Red Dead Redemption 2 after helping John and Sadie put an end to Micah. He simply walks away at the end of the game. In the original title, however, John manages to track down and kill Dutch, who had created a new gang of Native Americans.

Why did Dutch choose Micah over Arthur?

Micah killed Arthur because in the eyes of Dutch and the rest of the gang members who sided with him, he was seen as a traitor. Even though Arthur and the people who sided with him (Sadie, Charles, John, Susan) were morally right as the gang was deteriorating, Micah painted them as traitors and Dutch believed as such.

Is Micah alive in rdr1?

Before Micah can be killed, Dutch emerges from a cabin, guns drawn. Micah manages to overpower Sadie, holding her hostage, and a Mexican stand-off ensues between John, Micah and Dutch. Dutch initially appears to be on Micah's side, but eventually shoots Micah in the chest, mortally wounding him.

Who is the true villain of RDR2?

Micah Bell III is the main antagonist of the 2018 action-adventure game Red Dead Redemption II. He is the extremely psychopathic and dangerous hitman for the Van der Linde gang, in which he killed immoral amounts of people for money and sport.

What did Dutch do to the girl on the ferry?

Heidi McCourt was a young woman who was murdered some time during the Blackwater Massacre by Dutch van der Linde via a gunshot to the head. She has been described as an innocent, defenceless civilian who happened to be present on the ferry at Blackwater during the heist that was carried out by the Van der Linde gang.

Why did Dutch start to hate Arthur?

Arthur tells Dutch, “I gave all I had… I did.” Dutch knows Arthur is loyal to him, but he can't admit how far he has fallen from grace for allowing Micah to grab power and control from him. He is deeply remorseful but can't admit it because he is too arrogant and proud to admit what he did wrong.

Why did Javier turn evil?

Eventually, Javier became a notorious bounty hunter and revolutionary, fighting against what he saw as a corrupt system. He ended up killing a powerful, former military man in Punta Orgullo over a woman he was in love with. Fearing that his loved ones would suffer if he remained in Mexico, Javier fled to America.

Is Arthur mentioned in RDR1?

No. The only people created in Red Dead Redemption were John, Jack, Abigail, Dutch, Bill, and Javier. Arthur, Hosea, Sadie, Micah, and the others weren't created then. Remember that the previous game was written almost a decade ago.

Can John get Dutch's money?

During “American Venom”, John finds a chest that Dutch leaves him with that's assumed to have the Blackwater money. John himself gets roughly $20,000 (don't know if my memory is correct) and that's split with Charles and Sadie, so yeah.

What does Dutch say when he dies?

As Marston points a pistol at him, Dutch begins to speak, saying "We can't always fight nature John... We can't fight change. We can't fight nothin'." He also claims that (which are also his last words) "Our time is passed, John...", before falling to his death.

What can Arthur do that John Cannot?

In Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur Morgan can swim as long as his stamina holds out, which is a fairly long time. If John tries to take a dip in a lake, his stamina depletes almost instantly, and he quickly drowns.

Why is Arthur so much better than John?

Considering that Arthur was also the designated debt collector for the feared Van Der Linde gang, his physical presence and fighting ability speak for themselves. Considering that Arthur is larger than John, his penchant for brawling puts him a cut above Marston if they were to ever fight hand-to-hand.

Who betrayed Arthur and John?

Upon confronting them, Arthur discovers that Micah Bell has been betraying the gang by acting as an informant for the Pinkertons. He returns to Dutch to inform him of this, but Dutch turns on Arthur and the newly returned John. As Pinkertons invade the camp, Arthur and John flee.

Is Hosea Arthur's dad?

Arthur Morgan was effectively adopted by Hosea Matthews and Dutch Van Der Linde as a teenager, with the two operating as his parents. Indeed, Hosea and Dutch were both suitable father figures for Arthur Morgan in-game, making Dutch's descent into madness all the more disheartening.

Will Dutch send a member out to find Arthur?

If players do spend too much time away from the Red Dead Redemption 2 camp, Dutch will send out a member of the group to find Arthur Morgan and bring him back. Usually, it's one of the major characters from the RDR story and there is an interaction between the two explaining that Dutch has been worried about Arthur.

Who is Arthur Morgan's love interest?

Arthur rarely talks about Eliza and Isaac, suggesting that their deaths are still a sore spot for him. Arthur also falls in love with Mary Linton, and they eventually get engaged.