Was Dutch evil from the start? (2024)

Dutch is the villain of the game. Dutch begins the game as the charismatic leader of a rag tag group of criminals, vagrants, and destitute people who he took in and taught how to read. He was like a father to all of them, so the gang is extremely loyal to him.

When did Dutch become evil?

In Red Dead Redemption II, however, Dutch acted as an ally during the first five chapters, before becoming the secondary antagonist in the sixth chapter and epilogue.

Was Dutch crazy from the beginning?

I think Dutch was always crazy, he always seemed convinced that living an outlaws life was best for everyone and had delusions that they were noble. Hosea also kept him in check and was the voice of reason. But it was a combination of things that made him truly go off the deep end. Dutch never had standards.

Did Dutch become evil?

' He had grown more paranoid and manic after Hosea's death and the botched Saint Denis robbery, with Arthur even beginning to turn on him. So he turned on John as a result, viewing him as disloyal. This was solidified when he left John during their final heist and said he was dead.

Why does Dutch become evil?

In the mission “Urban Pleasures” Dutch gets a serious concussion, then you kind of see him start going mad, and then with Micah basically seducing him it does not help his brain work better. This all can be seen at the mission “Visiting Hours” where you save John.

Was Dutch Always A Bad Person Or Did He Change? Full Character Analysis Red Dead Redemption Lore

What mental illness does Dutch have in rdr2?

Part of his narcissism, yes, but the head injury…not so much. Dutch's personality and his environment are a perfect storm and vicious cycle all in one — the more irrational he becomes, the more problems he causes for himself which worsens his symptoms which draws more tension, hostility, and stress.

Did Dutch's head injury make him crazy?

These actions are very out of character for Dutch compared to the first half of the game, with the failed robbery in Saint Denis being the event that changed him. TL;Dr: Dutch had a brain injury that caused him to act irrationally and kill unnecessarily.

Did Dutch really care about Arthur?

I think Dutch still cared about Arthur but felt let down and disappointed by how little faith Arthur had in him. But there's a flip side to that coin. Arthur was disappointed by how Dutch was acting and killing when he didn't have too. No Dutch did not hate Arthur but he liked Micah better at the end.

Was Dutch ever a good guy?

He's very charismatic, intelligent and just has a way about him where as a player, you just want to please him. Dutch in his own mind, is the good guy until the end. I believe Dutch started out as a good man.

Does Dutch betray Arthur in RDR2?

He proves himself to not be the wise and thoughtful leader that Arthur and the other gang members believed him to be, and his recklessness results in the gang's downfall. Dutch stayed loyal to Micah in RDR2, but the decisions that led the Van Der Lindes towards their downfall were made by him and him alone.

Why did Dutch trust Micah?

Micah Was The Newcomer In The Van der Linde Gang

John, similarly, became a Van der Linde member at age 12 after he was almost executed for stealing, though Dutch stepped in right in the nick of time. Clearly Dutch felt like he owed Micah something in particular after Micah saved his life that fateful day.

Why did Dutch shoot Micah?

However, Dutch is a narcisstic egomaniac who would not admit that he was fooled so easily, so he kept that knowledge hidden from others. Dutch shoots Micah because he owes that to Arthur, in a way Dutch gains his redemption by shooting the man responsible for the downfall of his gang and the death of his surrogate son.

Why did Dutch go back to Micah?

Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Now, years later, Dutch Van Der Linde arrives at Micah's wanting to kill him. It's why Dutch tells John Marston he's there for the same reason John is.

Why does Dutch hate John?

' He had grown more paranoid and manic after Hosea's death and the botched Saint Denis robbery, with Arthur even beginning to turn on him. So he turned on John as a result, viewing him as disloyal. This was solidified when he left John during their final heist and said he was dead.

Will there be a rdr3?

So, if we base our judgement on that, we won't see a Red Dead Redemption 3 until 2026 at the earliest. However, there have been a few hints and teases from Rockstar Games that mean we'll certainly be back hunting bounties on horseback at some point.

Why did Dutch betray Arthur?

Also, Dutch misjudged Arthur's intentions all throughout the game because Dutch believed that Arthur would betray him as soon as they got the money (last train robbery). However, he was speechless upon hearing and dismissing Arthur's confession about Micah on ratting out on the gang.

Who was Dutch in love with?

Hosea and Dutch eventually met 14-year old orphan Arthur Morgan, who Dutch decided to take under his wing. Around this time, Dutch also began a romantic relationship with Susan Grimshaw, who also joined the gang. Their relationship would end, however, when Dutch fell in love with a woman named Annabelle.

Why were the Dutch so rich?

Taking advantage of a favorable agricultural base, the Dutch achieved success in the fishing industry and the Baltic and North Sea carrying trade during the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries before establishing a far-flung maritime empire in the seventeenth century.

Did Dutch regret leaving Arthur?

It's never fully stated if Dutch ended up regretting how things ended with his gang, and specifically Arthur. Despite whether or not he lost his mind, or was consumed by greed, it's hard to assume he never felt any regret or remorse over how things played out.

Did Dutch ever love Molly?

Rockstar Games' description of Molly. Molly was born into a wealthy family in Dublin, Ireland. She came to the United States searching for adventure, eventually joining Dutch van der Linde and his gang at some point prior to 1899. She and Dutch later became lovers.

Why did Dutch shoot the girl in Blackwater?

Arthur mentions that Dutch shot a woman in Blackwater. This was likely Dutch's attempt to create some distance between the gang and the Pinkertons. From there, several gang members slowed themselves down and, instead of helping them, Dutch left them behind so that he could escape.

Did Dutch know Micah was a rat?

Red Dead Redemption 2

As Arthur lays dying, pleading with Dutch to see that Micah is a rat, his former mentor begins to piece it all together. Dutch realizes what Arthur is saying is true and backs away, leaving Micah on the hillside.

Did Abigail slept with Dutch?

Now at the time RDR1 came out the van der linde gang was a lot smaller and characters like Arthur didn't exist, but we do know for sure that Abigail slept with Bill, Dutch, and Javier before she fell in love with John.

Why did Dutch stop trusting Arthur?

Dutch Would Have Eventually Seen Arthur As A Threat In RDR2 He repeatedly tells Arthur and others that they have to stick to his plan in order to survive, even as circ*mstances continue to worsen around them. Dutch wants to be the one in charge no matter what, and he wants his orders to be the law of the gang.

Who killed Dutch RDR?

Dutch himself is confronted by his former protégé, John, who chases him until Dutch is cornered near a cliff. After saying his piece, Dutch commits suicide, throwing himself from the cliff. Dutch van der Linde was portrayed by Benjamin Byron Davis.