Why did Dutch betray Arthur? (2024)

Dutch Would Have Eventually Seen Arthur As A Threat In RDR2 He repeatedly tells Arthur and others that they have to stick to his plan in order to survive, even as circ*mstances continue to worsen around them. Dutch wants to be the one in charge no matter what, and he wants his orders to be the law of the gang.

Did Dutch regret betraying Arthur?

It's never fully stated if Dutch ended up regretting how things ended with his gang, and specifically Arthur. Despite whether or not he lost his mind, or was consumed by greed, it's hard to assume he never felt any regret or remorse over how things played out.

Why didn't Dutch trust Arthur?

Also, Dutch misjudged Arthur's intentions all throughout the game because Dutch believed that Arthur would betray him as soon as they got the money (last train robbery). However, he was speechless upon hearing and dismissing Arthur's confession about Micah on ratting out on the gang.

Why did Dutch betray Micah?

However, Dutch is a narcisstic egomaniac who would not admit that he was fooled so easily, so he kept that knowledge hidden from others. Dutch shoots Micah because he owes that to Arthur, in a way Dutch gains his redemption by shooting the man responsible for the downfall of his gang and the death of his surrogate son.

Did Dutch actually love Arthur?

Dutch also regularly praised Arthur for his work in the gang, and also seemed to enjoy spending time with him. Dutch also seemed to fully trust Arthur and his judgment, giving him (along with Hosea) the same influence as himself in gang affairs, demonstrated before the Saint-Denis bank robbery.

What Happens If You Shoot Dutch Instead Of Micah At The Epilogue In Red Dead Redemption 2? (RDR2)

What mental illness does Dutch have in RDR2?

Ego-maniac, gang leader and lover of the phonograph. Dutch was a despot from the start.

Does Dutch regret Arthur's death?

He does regret it, because he eventually shoots Micah when John and Sadie confront him in the mountains. Dutch is just too headstrong and arrogant to admit he made a giant mistake.

Did Dutch realize Micah was a rat?

So, did Dutch know Micah was the rat? Not exactly. He knew Micah could be one, but he believed that he wasn't one for business purposes. That built up speculation is what led to Dutch testing Arthur and giving up on the gang's morale instead of just testing Micah.

Why does Micah laugh when Dutch shoots him?

Micah laughing after being mortally wounded by Dutch, despite obviously being in extreme pain, and then giving a nonchalant shrug moments after he's finished off by John could be evidence that Micah is so vindictive, he doesn't care about his own death as long as he knows John will eventually pay for his murder, since ...

Is Arthur Dutch's son?

Arthur Morgan was effectively adopted by Hosea Matthews and Dutch Van Der Linde as a teenager, with the two operating as his parents. Indeed, Hosea and Dutch were both suitable father figures for Arthur Morgan in-game, making Dutch's descent into madness all the more disheartening.

Does Arthur see Dutch as a father?

The bulk of Arthur Morgan's life was spent with Dutch and Hosea, being one of the earliest members of the Van Der Linde Gang. He joined up with them at age 14, and the two of them effectively became his father figures after Arthur's parents died long before RDR2.

Will Dutch send a member out to find Arthur?

If players do spend too much time away from the Red Dead Redemption 2 camp, Dutch will send out a member of the group to find Arthur Morgan and bring him back. Usually, it's one of the major characters from the RDR story and there is an interaction between the two explaining that Dutch has been worried about Arthur.

Who is Dutch's girlfriend in RDR2?

Rockstar Games' description of Molly. Molly was born into a wealthy family in Dublin, Ireland. She came to the United States searching for adventure, eventually joining Dutch van der Linde and his gang at some point prior to 1899. She and Dutch later became lovers.

Why did John never mention Arthur?

Arthur's last dying efforts (in my playthrough) were to save the Marstons, and among his last words were to “not look back.” TL;DR - John doesn't mention Arthur in RDR1 because 1) It hurts him to think of Arthur, 2) He's ashamed that Arthur saved his family, 3) Arthur said to not look back.

What caused Dutch to go crazy?

In the mission “Urban Pleasures” Dutch gets a serious concussion, then you kind of see him start going mad, and then with Micah basically seducing him it does not help his brain work better. This all can be seen at the mission “Visiting Hours” where you save John.

Did Dutch and Hosea raise Arthur?

Hosea described Arthur as originally being a "delinquent,” but he benefitted hugely from the mentoring of his two adoptive fathers, Hosea and Dutch. The pair brought Arthur away from the dirty city life and taught him how to shoot, rob, and ride a horse.

What did Dutch and Micah do to the girl?

He mentions that Micah Bell encouraged Dutch to kill her, and that Dutch later justified it by saying that it was what they had to do to survive. However it happened, her death remains a controversial and ambiguous topic.

Why does Dutch walk away after killing Micah?

Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies.

Can you find Dutch after beating rdr2?

Dutch Van der Linde walks away unharmed at the end of Red Dead Redemption 2 after helping John and Sadie put an end to Micah. He simply walks away at the end of the game. In the original title, however, John manages to track down and kill Dutch, who had created a new gang of Native Americans.

Who is the real traitor in RDR2?

Milton blatantly tells us that Micah is the traitor. He also mentions that Micah only rats after returning from Guarma. Mr. Milton has no reason to lie since he thought he was in control of the situation and Arthur is going to die right then and there.

Who was the real snitch in RDR2?

Molly confesses to telling the Pinkertons about the Saint Denis bank job, but when you confront Milton later he says that Molly told them nothing and Micah was the real traitor.

Who was the actual rat in RDR2?

Red Dead Redemption 2. It wasnt Micah. Abigail was the RAT of RDR 2. Abigail was ambitious woman who wanted to leave a peaceful life with John and Jack.

What did Dutch do after Arthur's death?

In reality, Dutch survived the bank robbery. He began to live between, and inspired Native Americans to follow his cause to stop the upcoming government. The Native Americans followed him, despite hating white people, eventually re-creating a new Dutch's Gang, this time known as "Dutch's Tribe".

Can John get Dutch's money?

During “American Venom”, John finds a chest that Dutch leaves him with that's assumed to have the Blackwater money. John himself gets roughly $20,000 (don't know if my memory is correct) and that's split with Charles and Sadie, so yeah.

Who is Arthur's son in RDR2?

Fictional character biography

Arthur joined Dutch van der Linde's gang when he was fourteen, having lost his parents at a young age, and soon became Dutch's first protégé. Arthur had a son, Isaac, with a waitress named Eliza; he demonstrated regular support for them until they were killed in a robbery.