Does Dutch regret Arthur's death? (2024)

It's never fully stated if Dutch ended up regretting how things ended with his gang, and specifically Arthur. Despite whether or not he lost his mind, or was consumed by greed, it's hard to assume he never felt any regret or remorse over how things played out.

What was Dutch thinking when Arthur was dying?

Dutch had mixed thoughts when Arthur died. He wasn't entirely sure that Arthur was telling the truth in his last words. That's why when John went after Micah in the mountains, Dutch was up there with him. It's because Dutch still had some trust in Micah up to that point when John convinced him otherwise.

Did Dutch really care about Arthur?

And the second Arthur's goals and opinions don't line up with his own, Dutch is basically done with him. So no, Dutch never really loved Arthur except as an extension of himself. But that's not real love. Dutch loved Arthur as long as he did as he was told.

Did Dutch realize his mistake?

Dutch finally realized what a bad man he has been and that he has lost his true “son” Arthur. He couldn't abandon his life as an outlow but he also couldn't live with Micah.

Does Dutch always betray Arthur?

If he believed that Arthur was after him, then he would betray him first. Dutch is sadly nowhere near the man that Arthur thought he was. While Micah played a major role in bringing down the Van Der Lindes, Dutch was always going to turn on Arthur, and likely the rest of the gang eventually.

Can You Find Dutch After Chapter 6 & Before The End Of The Epilogue In Red Dead Redemption 2? (RDR2)

Why did Dutch trust Micah or Arthur?

Clearly Dutch felt like he owed Micah something in particular after Micah saved his life that fateful day. But there must have been countless times over the years in which the other gang members saved Dutch's neck, so it doesn't exactly explain why he felt more inclined to trust Micah over everyone else.

Why didn t Dutch listen to Arthur?

Dutch Felt Everyone Was Betraying Him

As one of the original gang members, Arthur is one of the only people that can attempt to talk some sense into Dutch. However, it doesn't go well. Dutch accuses Arthur and everyone else who disagrees with his ideas of betraying him.

What mental illness does Dutch have in rdr2?

All in all, it's clear that Dutch is suffering from a personality disorder, and he's a textbook narcissist. Narcissism is defined by dramatic and exaggerated traits, emotional intensity, as well as acting erratically and unpredictable. Dutch's whole schtick is dramatic.

Did Dutch change after he hit his head?

Although Dutch did kill an innocent girl during the Blackwater robbery, this kind of behaviour became far more common after his head injury. These actions are very out of character for Dutch compared to the first half of the game, with the failed robbery in Saint Denis being the event that changed him.

Did Dutch ever love Molly?

Molly was born into a wealthy family in Dublin, Ireland. She came to the United States searching for adventure, eventually joining Dutch van der Linde and his gang at some point prior to 1899. She and Dutch later became lovers.

Did Dutch love Arthur in the end?

I think Dutch still cared about Arthur but felt let down and disappointed by how little faith Arthur had in him. But there's a flip side to that coin. Arthur was disappointed by how Dutch was acting and killing when he didn't have too. No Dutch did not hate Arthur but he liked Micah better at the end.

What were Arthur's last words to Dutch?

At the end there, he looks at Dutch and says "I gave you all I had, Dutch. I really did." Flashback to the beginning. Arthurs riding with Charles.

Did Dutch know Micah was a rat?

So, did Dutch know Micah was the rat? Not exactly. He knew Micah could be one, but he believed that he wasn't one for business purposes. That built up speculation is what led to Dutch testing Arthur and giving up on the gang's morale instead of just testing Micah.

Did Dutch regret not helping Arthur?

As their confrontation with John commenced, Dutch ends up shooting Micah and mortally wounding him, thereby implying that he regretted not acting on Arthur's request to kill Micah beforehand.

When did Dutch realize Arthur was right?

As Arthur lays dying, pleading with Dutch to see that Micah is a rat, his former mentor begins to piece it all together. Dutch realizes what Arthur is saying is true and backs away, leaving Micah on the hillside.

Why didn't Dutch save John?

' He had grown more paranoid and manic after Hosea's death and the botched Saint Denis robbery, with Arthur even beginning to turn on him. So he turned on John as a result, viewing him as disloyal. This was solidified when he left John during their final heist and said he was dead.

Why did Dutch walk away at the end?

Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies.

What does Dutch suffer from?

In yet another job that goes south early into the game, the gang's fearless leader takes a major blow to the noggin and becomes dazed for the rest of the mission. The theory posits that Dutch was left with a brain injury as a result of the blow, and that this ultimately leads to his downward spiral.

Did Dutch go crazy or was he always like that?

Why did Dutch change so much in the Red Dead Storyline? After him being a charismatic and likeable character in Red Dead Redemption 2, he became a dark and murderous psychopath. He was being manipulated by Micah since the start but Hosea kept him in line.

Who had the saddest death in RDR2?

John's death is undoubtedly the most tragic of the series. For one thing, the death comes out of nowhere. While we all accepted Arthur's eventual demise, John's death at the hands of Ross comes as a major surprise and story twist. His background was also more tragic than Arthur's.

What mental illness does Arthur have?

The Pseudobulbar Affect In Joker

In the film it's noted that the condition can be caused by brain damage, and in the third act the source of Arthur's brain injury - the likely cause of his uncontrollable laughing - is revealed.

What illness does Hosea have RDR2?

Hosea Matthews may have been killed by Agent Milton, but it turns out he was also sick. Throughout the game, players can hear Dutch and other members of the gang discuss the fact that Hosea is suffering from what seems to be a certain type of lung disease.

Why is Abigail always mad at John?

Abigail's anger towards John can be a little tough to swallow at times during the epilogue, but it comes from a place that makes sense. The Marstons went through a lot over the course of the game, and Abigail's high emotion combined with John's irresponsibility led to their clashes.

Why is Arthur worth more than Dutch?

Between breaking into mansions, robbing banks, and attacking the law, Arthur's loyalty to the Van Der Linde gang likely put thousands more dollars on his head. Assuming each 1899 dollar would be worth over $30 today, it's no wonder why Dutch's plans always involved running far away and trying to start fresh.

What did Arthur say to Dutch before he died?

What was Dutch thinking when Arthur told him he gave him everything he had and that Micah was a rat? This happens in the final mission of Red Dead Redemption 2, right before Arthur dies.